Logo
All Random Solved Random Open
OPEN
Let $d_k(p)$ be the density of those integers whose $k$th smallest prime factor is $p$ (i.e. if $p_1<p_2<\cdots$ are the primes dividing $n$ then $p_k=p$).

For fixed $k\geq 1$ is $d_k(p)$ unimodular in $p$? That is, it first increases in $p$ until its maximum then decreases.

Erdős believes that this is not possible, but could not disprove it. He could show that $p_k$ is about $e^{e^k}$ for almost all $n$, but the maximal value of $d_k(p)$ is assumed for much smaller values of $p$, at \[p=e^{(1+o(1))k}.\]

A similar question can be asked if we consider the density of integers whose $k$th smallest divisor is $d$. Erdős could show that this function is not unimodular.

Cambie [Ca25] has shown that $d_k(p)$ is unimodular for $1\leq k\leq 3$ and is not unimodular for $4\leq k\leq 20$.